The Top 6 Lakes around Southold
Looking to visit the best lakes around Southold? After all, there’s nothing better than the serenity of the lakeshore — or a quick dip when the weather’s warm. So, browse our list of Southold’s top lakes below as recommended by the komoot community, and experience more on your next adventure!
Last updated: December 11, 2025
Mashomack Preserve
Highlight • Forest
Nestled on Shelter Island, Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre natural wonderland. It features diverse ecosystems from woodlands to tidal creeks, offering picturesque trails for hikers. Rich in biodiversity, it's a …
Tip by
Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge
Highlight • Natural
The 187-acre Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge on Long Island's north shore protects the Jessup's Neck peninsula, separating Little Peconic and Noyack Bays.
While open for visitors, the refuge …
While open for visitors, the refuge …
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Inlet Pond County Park
Highlight • Lake
Be enchanted by the vibrant flutter of butterflies in the dedicated butterfly garden. This colorful haven is a delight for families and nature enthusiasts alike.
Tip by
Nicoll's Creen
Highlight • Lake
Nicoll's Creen is a marshy bay, part of Mashomack Preserve. This area is great for birdwatching and a scenic spot for a break.
Tip by
Mashomack Preserve
Highlight • Forest
Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre preserve on Shelter Island. It is known for its diverse ecosystems and picturesque trails.
Tip by
Sign up for free to discover even more lakes around Southold.
Sign up for free
Already have an account?
Most popular routes around Southold
Most popular attractions around Southold
Get inspired with the komoot mobile app
With a free komoot account, you can easily find, customize, and navigate endless outdoor adventures around London and beyond.
Explore more
Still not found your perfect lake around Southold? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.
BridgehamptonDix HillsMelvilleShelter Island HeightsShelter IslandNorth HavenNoyackNorthwest HarborSag HarborWainscottWest BabylonNorth AmityvilleLindenhurstNorth LindenhurstAmityvilleGilgoEast FarmingdaleCopiagueIslipDeer ParkNorth Bay ShoreBay ShoreBaywoodBrentwoodGreenport WestVillage of GreenportOrientEast MarionDering Harbor
Get ready to conquer new peaks
Sign up for Free