The Top 5 Lakes around Islip
Looking to visit the best lakes around Islip? After all, there’s nothing better than the serenity of the lakeshore — or a quick dip when the weather’s warm. So, browse our list of Islip’s top lakes below as recommended by the komoot community, and experience more on your next adventure!
Last updated: November 8, 2025
View of the waterfall at the Belmont Lake outlet
Highlight • Viewpoint
From this spot you get a nice view of a small waterfall flowing out of Belmont Lake into Carl's River. This is a pleasant spot to pause as you ride around Belmont Lake State Park and the surrounding area.
Tip by
Southards Pond
Highlight • Lake
Southards Pond is the main attraction with Southards Pond Park. The main trail basically walks up to the shore of the water on the west side of the reservoir and …
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Southern end of Belmont Lake
Highlight • Waterfall
The area where Belmont Lake funnels back into the Carlls River at the southern end of the reservoir is a popular viewing spot of the water. There is a bridge …
Tip by
Blydenburgh County Park
Highlight • Forest
In Blydenburgh County Park, explore lush hills and valleys at the Nissequogue River headwaters, and take leisurely strolls through the historic mill district, showcasing the 1798 "New Mill" and other charming structures.
Tip by
Argyle Lake
Highlight • Lake
Argyle Lake, situated in Belmont Lake State Park, boasts a serene 0.8-mile loop. Meandering through wooded landscapes with occasional open vistas and glimpses of the lake, this trail offers a tranquil escape.
Tip by
Most popular attractions around Islip
Get inspired with the komoot mobile app
With a free komoot account, you can easily find, customize, and navigate endless outdoor adventures around London and beyond.
Explore more
Still not found your perfect lake around Islip? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.
BridgehamptonDix HillsMelvilleShelter Island HeightsShelter IslandNorth HavenNoyackSag HarborNorthwest HarborWainscottNorth AmityvilleLindenhurstCopiagueWest BabylonNorth LindenhurstAmityvilleGilgoEast FarmingdaleNorth Bay ShoreBrentwoodBay ShoreDeer ParkBaywoodSoutholdGreenport WestVillage of GreenportDering HarborEast MarionOrient
Get ready to conquer new peaks
Sign up for Free